Maryland and D.C. to sue President Trump for violating U.S. Constitution through hotel business

The Trump International Hotel Washington D.C.

The attorneys general in Maryland and Washington, D.C. have filed a lawsuit claiming that foreign and domestic government payments to Trump Hotels violate the U.S. Constitution.

According to Reuters, the attorneys general will seek an order in U.S. district court in Maryland that would prevent President Trump from accepting government payments beyond his salary. According to the claim, the payments not only draw business away from Maryland and D.C. venues, but they also pressure local governments into giving Trump's hotel chains special treatment. The local governments are faced with an "intolerable dilemma" when the President requests they grant his businesses land-use permissions or favors, the attorneys general allege.

Furthermore, the attorneys general have claimed that if the court does not grant the requests, they could be "susceptible to injury resulting from budgetary decisions that are subject to the corruption influence of emoluments." 

FREE DAILY NEWSLETTER

Like this story? Subscribe to Operations!

Hospitality professionals turn to Operations as their go-to source for breaking news on guest rooms, food & beverage, hospitality trends, management, and more. Sign up today to get news and updates delivered to your inbox daily and read on the go.

The case brought by the two Democratic attorneys general may stand a better chance in court than the first government action over allegations that Trump violated the Constitution's emoluments clauses. These clauses bar the President from accepting gifts from foreign governments without congressional and domestic government approval under any circumstances.

Trump's businesses faced a similar lawsuit brought in January by several plaintiffs including an ethics nonprofit group. Democratic lawmakers have argued that these payments could be corrupting influences on Trump. In response, the Trump Organization has stated that it plans to donate profits from foreign government deals to the U.S. Treasury. However, the organization will not require the customers to identify themselves.

The Trump International Hotel has, in some ways, become a target for those in opposition of the president and a symbol of his conflicts of interest.

President Trump continues to own his businesses, including the Trump International Hotel in Washington, although he handed over management of Trump Organization in January to his elder sons. Therefore, the president can still profit from them at any time. The Justice Department argued that the plaintiffs cannot allege enough specific harm caused by Trump's businesses, and therefore lacked legal standing.

The government also stated that Trump hotel profits do not fit the definition of an improper payment under the Constitution. Payments to Trump Organization hotels do not violate the emoluments clause, they claimed, which is intended to cover personal services performed by the president. 

Democratic attorneys general have successfully challenged Trump policies, especially in blocking the president's executive orders restricting travel from some Muslim-majority countries. 

Suggested Articles

The company expects to open more than 30 new Comfort properties in the market by 2033 via its existing franchising agreement with Choice Hotels Japan.

While consolidated revenue for the quarter was up 10.9 percent as reported, it was up 4.1 percent on a like-for-like basis compared to Q3 2018.

Sam Schwartz has spent more than four years with First Hospitality, including most recently as a general manager.